Best Overall
CRAFTSMAN CMXEVBE17250 2.5 Gallon 2.5 Peak HP Wet Dry Shop Vacuum
Our verdict: The right-sized shop vac for a one-car garage: small enough to hang on a wall, strong enough to matter.
The CRAFTSMAN is a 2.5 gallon unit with a 2.5 peak HP motor, and it sits in the sweet spot between a toy-sized bucket vac and a full 5 gallon machine. That tank holds enough to clear a spilled bag of potting soil or a flooded utility sink corner without stopping every few minutes to empty it.
It takes first place because it is the most balanced machine here. It has more capacity than the 1.5 gallon Armor All, it costs noticeably less than the Vacmaster below it, and the brand name brings accessory availability that off-brand models sometimes lack. Compared with the WEN it gives up the HEPA-style filter and blower function, so it is a general-purpose cleaner rather than a fine-dust specialist.
Buy it for garage cleanups, car interiors, basement drips and light workshop debris. The caveat is the usual one for any small wet-dry vac: the stock filter is not meant for drywall dust, and the cord and hose are short enough that a large room means an extension cord.
- Tank
- 2.5 gallon
- Motor
- 2.5 peak HP
- Type
- Portable wet/dry
- Price bucket
- $25 to $50
What we like
- +Tank size suits garages and car interiors
- +Strong brand means easy accessory finding
- +Budget price for a 2.5 peak HP motor
- +Small enough to hang on a shelf
Watch out for
- −Stock filter struggles with fine dust
- −Short cord needs an extension often
Buy it if: Anyone who wants one small vac for the garage, car and basement.
Skip it if: You sand drywall or clean fine ash and need real filtration.





