Top 5 Best 50 Gallon Electric Water Heater 2021

Best 50-gallon electric water heater. When the winter season is just about to come, the holiday season is approaching quickly. It is time to get your water heating system is ready to deliver adequate hot water for the usage of all family members.

If you notice that the current water heater is not running effectively and is taking a long time to heat the water, it is time for you to purchase a new water heater. You may want to find the best 50-gallon electric water heater.

In this article, we have selected the top rated 50-gallon water heaters. We discover the selection from the positive reviews about them from the verified purchasers. Read all the comparison, pros, cons, specifications, ratings, our favorites and reviews of these and you can make a purchasing decision accurately.


Our Quick Overview

  1. Most Durable Electric Water Heater: Rheem MR50245 Marathon Tall Electric Water Heater
  2. Best for Energy Efficiency: Westinghouse Electric 50-Gallon Water Heater WER052C2X055N06
  3. Best Overall: A.O. Smith ENS-50 ProMax Short 50-Gallon Electric Water Heater
  4. Best Short Electric Water Heater: A.O. Smith PNS-50 ProMax Short Electric Water Heater
  5. Best Commercial Electric Water Heater: RHEEM-RUUD ES50-18-G

Our Top Picks

Primeareviews earns a commission through the affiliate links at no additional cost to you.

Product Type Power (Watt) Ratings
Rheem MR50245 Marathon Tall Electric Water Heater Residential 4,500 watts 9.1
Westinghouse Electric 50-Gallon Water Heater WER052C2X055N06 Residential 5,500 watts 9.1
A.O. Smith ENS-50 ProMax Short 50-Gallon Electric Water Heater Residential 5,500 watts 8.8
A.O. Smith PNS-50 ProMax Short Electric Water Heater Residential 4,500 watts 8.8
RHEEM-RUUD ES50-18-G Commercial 18,000 watts 8.9

The advantage of purchasing the electric water heater

  • The most important advantage of using an electric water heater is the affordable price. Gas-powered water heaters are more expensive, with some models have double the price of an electric water heater unit.
  • Electric water heaters stand out for consumers because it lasts longer than gas-powered water heater models. Gas-powered water heaters unit need a pilot light to operate, which deteriorates over time. This deterioration needs additional maintenance when compared to electric water heaters.
  • Electric water heaters are much safer to use and install. Gas-powered appliances may be hazardous when there are leaks. So it would need extra precautions to be taken when installing gas-powered water heater units. It means it can cost extra money and time. Electric water heaters do not need a similar type of safety measure. There is no need for extra hassles, and extra costs may be avoided.
  • Electric water heaters do not need to be connected to a gas line. Every home has a connection to the electrical grid.
  • The installation cost of a gas water heater can be more expensive — the cost of installation may be a few hundred dollars more per unit to install.

How to buy the right 50-gallon electric water heater

1. The type

Before purchasing a new 50-gallon water heater, you have to know the model or the type of water heater. In today’s market, there are two types of water heaters which are the tankless model and the storage tank model.

The storage tank model means that there is a reservoir tank for storing water (holding heated water). You have to accommodate some space for the storage tank.

While the tankless model means that the 50-gallon water heater has no tank for storing the heated water. You will only need minimal space to install the tankless water heater.


2. The size

Forty gallons is the standard size water heater. The water heater unit does not require much space around it to run.

You make sure there is enough space when there is someone to come in and service the 50-gallon electric water heater. The size of the water heater depends on the hot water needs in the house.

The factor of how much hot water you need must be considered when purchasing a 50-gallon electric water heater. A large house must need a large water heater to serve all your hot water required.

It would be best if you keep in mind that the bigger the water heater, the more space it will need. A bigger storage tank water heater would need more space to serve the large tank. You will also need to accommodate a large tankless water heater.


3. Hot water requirement

Consider the number of people in your house. The typical person uses about twenty to thirty gallons of hot water every day.

The FHR (first-hour rating) will help you determine how well the unit will operate during a busy period. See the total BTU load of all of the appliances in your home that are running at the same time, such as the hot tub, the laundry, the dishwasher, the toilet, and the shower.

The GPM (gallons per minute rating) means that you can determine how many gallons of water can be filled in the tank per minute — the lower volume of water used per minute, the higher of hot water.


4. Energy source

When there is a power supply line, this is the best place to place your water heater. The 50-gallon water heater has to be powered by solar, gas, propane, electricity, or geothermal energy.

The water heater must be placed in a strategic location for easy installation and connectivity.


Best 50 Gallon Electric Water Heater Reviews

We researched online to put together the top 50 Gallon Electric Water Heaters available on the market today. Combining mostly on consumer reviews and product information, we recommend our favorite products.


Most Durable

Rheem MR50245 Marathon Tall Electric 50-Gallon Water Heater

50-Gallon Electric Water Heater

Most Durable Electric Water Heater

Buy At Amazon
Buy At Home Depot

Average Ratings: 9.0

  • Durability: 9.5
  • Easy to use: 9.0
  • Price: 8.5

Our tips

  • They do not have an issue with being exposed to the unpleasant sulfur smell and problems with the deteriorated anode rod. The design is lightweight, and the handling is secure. This Rheem or Ruud Marathon comes with a high-quality tank, high energy factor EF, and excellent service network from the well-established company.
  • It comes with a six years warranty for replacement parts. It has the upper heating element that is protected against dry-firing, while the lower element is stainless steel.
  • The tank is made of lightweight polybutene, seamless, blow-molded, and does not leak. Its high-efficiency energy factor is 0.94, with losses of only 5-degree Fahrenheit of heat in 24 hours. When running, the delivery rate is 20 GPH, but in the first hour, the delivery is 61 GPH. The water heater requires less maintenance involved, no hydrogen gases, and no rotten egg odor.
  • The will be no rust, no corrosion with the non-metallic water tank. The bowl-shaped bottom will let you drain the water completely.

Features that we like

  • Overheat Protection
  • Temperature Pressure Relief Valve

Why we like it (Pros)

  • Best value for the money
  • Durable and reliable
  • Eliminate smell
  • Rust-free and well-insulated
  • Reduced energy consumption
  • Can resists salt air, dents, and scratches

Why we do not like it (Cons)

  • May need to replace with better anode rod
  • Plastic tank requires frequent replacement
  • Leaks may occur after a while
  • The thermostat may fail after a while
GTIN or UPC 020352473598
Capacity (gallon) 50 gallon
Weight 103 pounds
First-hour rating 57 gallon per hour
Dimension 23.5 x 23.5 x 62.75 inches
Warranty 6 year
Certifications and Listings UL Listed
Efficiency level High
Wattage 4,500 watts
Tank lining material Glass

“This is one great 50-gallon electric water heater for those on well water. If you like to get rid of the smell from anode rod chemical reaction, this 50-gallon electric water heater works great. There is no need for an Anode rod. You will be satisfied with its lightweight and insulated features!”


Best for Energy Efficiency

Westinghouse Electric 50-Gallon Water Heater WER052C2X055N06

Westinghouse Electric 50-Gallon Water Heater

Best For Energy Efficiency

Buy At Amazon
Buy At Home Depot

Average Ratings: 9.1

  • Durability: 9.0
  • Easy to use: 9.0
  • Price: 9.5

Our tips

  • This Westinghouse Electric Water Heater with Durable 316L Stainless Steel Tank, (52 gallons) is a durable and reliable electric water heater. It comes with a stainless steel tank that eliminates the need for the anode rod, corrosion, hydrogen sulfide gas, development of bacteria, rotten egg odor, and scale build-up. The whole water heater is insulated with heavy-duty insulation to keep the heat inside for more savings.
  • You can handle it securely due to its lightweight design. The tank capacity is 52 gallons that can serve hot water for four to five people and can supply one to two bathrooms.
  • All of the electric heating components are made of high-grade stainless steel. That makes these components a low watt density, durable, and resistant to corrosion and hard water effect.
  • You can install the electric water heater easily because the water connections are located at the top of the water heater unit. This water heater model from Westinghouse can deliver long draws of hot water, with the first-hour delivery is around 84 GPH.
  • The hot water delivery makes it saves money and time. The water heater comes with a limited lifetime warranty to make sure many years of high performance of water heating.

Features that we like

  • For 3 to 5 people
  • Get rid of bacteria
  • Easy to install
  • Easy replacement
  • Stainless steel elements
  • Durable and lightweight
  • High recovery rates
  • Low standby heat losses

Why we like it (Pros)

  • It is lightweight: 118 pounds
  • Very stylish and sleek design with coated faux stainless steel material
  • The display is easy to tuch for controling the temperature
  • Thee levels of nitrogen oxide emissions are reduced by the combustion control system
  • 97 percent thermally efficient to save energy, save money and friendly to the environment.

Why we do not like it (Cons)

  • Medium noise level
  • May be harder to start
  • It may require frequent resetting
GTIN or UPC 763160005758
Capacity (gallon) 52 gallon
Weight 118 pounds
First-hour rating 71 gallon per hour
Dimension 19.5 x 19.5 x 66.8 inches
Warranty 6 year
Certifications and Listings ETL Listed
Efficiency level Super High
Wattage 5,500 watts
Tank lining material Stainless Steel

“When it is time to replace your whirlpool, this electric water heater will please you with the quality it offers. The water heater would be a very good fit and has a high-quality drain valve. The placement of the drain valve is high enough from the floor level to drain out sediment easily. It is certainly a lot better than cheap plastic valves on most electric water heaters. The Westinghouse Electric water heater heats very quickly and has excellent insulation because the outer surface of the tank remains close to room temperature. The high-grade stainless steel tank should last a lifetime!”


Best Overall

A.O. Smith ENS-50 ProMax Short 50-Gallon Electric Water Heater

Best Overall

Buy At Amazon

Average Ratings: 8.8

  • Durability: 9.0
  • Easy to use: 9.0
  • Price: 8.5

Our tips

  • It is also qualified for most utility rebate programs, and it is equipped with long-lasting low-watt density copper heating elements, a certified T&P relief valve, and Permaglas glass coating (Blue Diamond Glass Coating) that protects from corrosion.
  • The tube of the water heater is the Dynaclean dip tube that can lower sediment and lime buildup for many years. You can choose between many installation choices such as lowboy, short, and tall models. The water heater is durable, with a tamper-resistant brass drain valve.
  • The electric water heater comes with a PEX cross-linked polymer that can decrease lime and reduce sediment buildup. This will be very helpful when you have severe water conditions. The water heater will produce hot water when the water’s pH level is below or above average.
  • You can enjoy a long more than 20 minutes of a single hot water shower and can fill up a bathtub in just 7 minutes.

Features that we like

  • For 3 to 4 people
  • Safe operation
  • Easy temperature control
  • Energy-efficient model
  • Reliable copper heating elements

Why we like it (Pros)

  • CoreGuard technology, commercial-grade electric heating elements (stainless steel) that last a lifetime protected with aluminum shell
  • High First Hour recovery and rating
  • Very esy to install anywhere
  • It can provide enough hot water for an average family of four or three

Why we do not like it (Cons)

  • Complaints about the customer service and tech support
  • First start noise
GTIN or UPC 671657197100
Capacity (gallon) 50 gallon
Weight 125 pounds
First-hour rating 57 gallon per hour
Dimension 49.25 x 23 x 23 inches
Warranty 6 year
Certifications and Listings UL safety listing
Efficiency level High
Wattage 5,500 watts
Estimated energy cost $569/year
Anode rods Stainless steel core

“This water heater is very easy to install, less cost to maintain. Draining the entire tank will take about 25 to 30 minutes to heat the entire water heater back to the hot temperature. It is sufficient for a household of 4. You will be surprised at how much you can save on energy costs!”


Best Short Electric Water Heater

A.O. Smith PNS-50 ProMax Short Electric Water Heater

Best Short Electric Water Heater

Buy At Amazon

Average Ratings: 8.8

  • Durability: 9.0
  • Easy to use: 9.0
  • Price: 8.5

Our tips

  • You can quickly install this A.O. Smith PNS-50 ProMax Short Electric Water Heater. It comes with an installation manual and user guide.
  • The water heater can deliver at a reasonable rate and is durable. The price is affordable and has an excellent value for money. You can take a shower for as long as 26 minutes of a single hot water shower and can fill up a bathtub in just 7 minutes.
  • This electric water heater provides the best qualities of a water heater but at a much lower price. It is equipped with 4500-watt dual heating elements, PEX cross-linked polymer diffuser dip, stainless steel construction, stainless steel anode rod, and non-CFC insulation.
  • The water heater by A.O. is an efficient and very environment-friendly water heater. This 50-gallon electric water heater is easy to install, very durable, and delivers hot water at an excellent rate.

Features that we like

  • Non-CFC insulation material
  • Side temperature and pressure relief valve
  • Permaglas glass coating
  • A stainless steel anode rod
  • High-quality material 
  • Durable

Why we like it (Pros)

  • Fast recovery and reliable operation
  • Diffuser dip tube that can lessen sediment and lime buildup
  • With the Eco-friendly non-CFC foam insulation, this electric water heater can churn out a high energy factor for lowering operating costs
  • Its glass coating can withstand corrosion
  • When it is time for maintenance, users can easily drain through the female hose fitting
  • The anode rodes are made of magnesium that can resist corrosion
  • Long warranty period
  • Adequate documentation

Why we do not like it (Cons)

  • Some customer service complaints from verified purchasers
GTIN or UPC 671657200411
Capacity (gallon) 50 gallon
Weight 176 pounds
First-hour rating 62 gallons
Dimension 24 x 24 x 50 inches
Warranty 6 year
Certifications and Listings UL safety listing
Efficiency level High
Wattage 4,500 watts
Estimated energy cost $569/year
Heating elements Dual copper

“The water heater is easy to install, has a good price, and recommended for a water heater with durability and energy-saving cost!”


Best Commercial Electric Water Heater

RHEEM-RUUD ES50-18-G

Best Commercial Electric Water Heater

Buy At Amazon
Buy At Home Depot

Average Ratings: 8.9

  • Durability: 9.0
  • Easy to use: 9.2
  • Price: 8.5

Our tips

  • If you are looking for a heavy-duty and for commercial use 50-gallon electric water heater that can be utilized as a booster or eyewash station in an industrial building, this is the right option. We rate this heater as the best commercial electric water heater.
  • It features Lifeguard™ stainless steel elements that is corrosion-resistant and withstand burn out.
  • The tank had been designed to last a lifetime with its steel formulation, high temperature porcelain enamel for a superior quality tank.
  • There are two anode rods to have a long life and corrosion resistance.
  • If you are in the food business, this 50-gallon electric water heater, one unit can serve as a booster heater to supply hot water requirements of dishwashers. It will supply two temperatures.

Features that we like

  • Glass-Lined Tank
  • Thick foam insulation
  • Temperature Pressure Relief Valve
  • Overheat Protection

Why we like it (Pros)

  • The recovery is excellent
  • Long life tank design made of steel
  • No chance of heat loss due to the thick foam insulation

Why we do not like it (Cons)

  • You have to call a plumber to install the water heater
GTIN or UPC 203524078832
Capacity (gallon) 50 gallon
Weight 270 pounds
First-hour rating 133 gallons
Dimension 26.25 x 32 x 43.63 inches
Warranty 1 year
Certifications and Listings CSA Listed, UL Listed
Efficiency level High
Wattage 18,000 watts
Heating elements Stainless steel

“A perfect option for commercial dishwashers and booster!”


What you should know about water heater

1. The time for a replacement

All water heaters will provide a sign when they require to be replaced. If your water heater is about seven years old, the Department of Energy recommends that you should purchase a new water heater.

If you see the water heater is leaking, you should consider buying a new one. If you are not getting as much hot water out of it compared to its original condition, the water heater gives a sign of failure.

You should replace your water heater if the water heater is producing noisy operation, slow recovery, calcium buildup, and your water heater does not produce any hot water at all.

A water heater could last from ten to fifteen years with regular maintenance.

2. The efficiency

Water heating will contribute to about fifteen percent to twenty percent of your energy bill. The Department of Energy stated that an average household spends from $400 to $600 every year on hot water, and uses sixty-four gallons every day.

A high-efficiency water heater is very crucial because it decreases the amount of energy you use. Reduce the amount of energy means lowering your energy costs.

Each water heater is given an Energy Factor. It is a calculation of the efficiency of a water heater when running for 24 hours.

The Department of Energy counts the Energy Factor by operating a simulated use test on each model of the water heater. A water heater with a higher Energy Factor rating uses less energy.

The best and easy way to make the water heater efficient is to keep it regularly maintained. Regular maintenance will increase the lifespan.


How to maintain your water heater

1. Inspect the anode rod

  • Find the tank’s drain cock. Put a hose to it and let out a 1 gallon of water.
  • Fit one 1/16-inch socket onto the rod’s hex head under its top plate and unscrew the rod. If it is less than half-inch thick or it is coated with calcium, buy a replacement.
  • If you have the replacement, wrap the threads with Teflon tape. Put the replacement back in the tank, and tighten it tightly.

2. Drain and wash out sediment from the tank

  • Drain all of the water in the tank. Stir up the sediment on the tank’s bottom by opening the water supply valve.
  • Drain and repeat the practice until you see only clean water comes out of the hose. Close the drain cock, and refill the tank with water, and turn its power back on.

3. Temperature adjustment

  • Please search for the temperature dial on the side of the tank. When you find it, start unscrewing its cover.
  • Get a flathead screwdriver and adjust the dial to 120 degrees with it. For every ten degrees, the temperature is lessened. This lessening will save about five percent of energy costs.
  • Turn the thermostat down to the lowest setting whenever you go away from home.

4. Heater insulation

  • Purchase and cut an insulating blanket. Make sure the cut is to fit around the TPOR value, the temperature control, and pipes of the tank.
  • Wrap the side of the tank with the insulating blanket, and using a foil tape seal cuts the wrapper. Never cover the tops of gas or oil water heaters.

5. Drain the tank

  • Drain the tank about four to six times per year to get rid of sediment and debris. Do this by turning off the cold water supply.
  • Drain the water out of the tank until the water is clear. If you see the cloudy water remain to be seen, open the water supply valve again and drain the tank again.
  • By cleaning the sediment will make the unit run more quietly.

First-hour rating of electric water heater

According to the Department of Energy, to measure the proper size of a water heater for your home you need to use the water heater’s first-hour rating. This rating is the number of gallons of hot water the electric water heater  (or other water heaters) can supply in 1 hour when the tank is full of hot water.

Usually, the manual from a manufacturer or brand provides the information of first-hour rating. You need to find a 50-gallon water heater model with a first-hour rating that fits within one or two gallons of the peak hour demand for your home.

Here is how you estimate the peak hour of your home.

  • Select the time of day the whole family use the most hot water in the whole home. Count the number of family members.
  • Estimate your maximum usage or the peak hour demand of hot water during one hour of the day.

Estimating Peak Hour Demand

First-hour Rating Example

Usage Avg gal/usage   Times used   Gallons per hour
5 showers 10 x 5 x 50
1 handwashing 3 x 5 x 15
Clothes washer 7 x 1 x 7
1 shaving 2 x 1 x 2
        Peak Hour Demand = 74 gallons/hour

The table shows a total peak hour demand of 74 gallons. Therefore, this household would need a water heater model with a first hour rating of 75 to 80 gallons.

Here is the formula of first-hour rating=

tank capacity X 0.70 + recovery rate = first-hour rating

For a 50-gallon water heater and a recovery rate of 50 gph=

50 X 0.70 + 50 = 85 gph

This formula result means that a household can get 85 gallons of hot water in the first hour of use. With this information, you discover an estimate on your daily hot water usage. Use this formula when buying a new water heater for your family.


Top 5 Best 50 Gallon Electric Water Heater 2021
Scroll to top